I thought about starting this as a "when I was vegan" post, but really it's relevant to me
now and is--or should be--relevant to most people who eat food. Err, that would be most of you. Maybe all of you! (I mean, I assume you eat food if you're reading my blog. I meant the dairy issue.) What I want to do today is talk about dairy, issues related to dairy consumption, and dairy alternatives. The good, the bad, and the ugly. I doubt I'll get to everything in this post, so please forgive any omissions. And please also forgive my ramblings. You see, I'm looking a lot like a steamed lobster right now because I didn't think to re-apply my sunscreen during my five-hour stint in peak sun today, and my brains got to be working on a lesser capacity as I write. (Feel free to comment about them, though! There's a
lot to talk about.)
There's been some research that shows nearly half--if not more--the world's population is lactose intolerant. I don't know if that means all those that are
lactose intolerant have GI symptoms. I also don't know if that includes those who are
casein-intolerant like me. (What that means, basically, is that I can't have
any dairy--butter, cream, cheese, etc. Even Lactaid--which would kind of freak me out as being Franken-milk anyway, beyond the factory farm issue.) I also do not know whether that includes the
dairy-allergic, or if it's even relevant. Just that a good portion of the world's population is--or
should be--dairy free.
Even if those people don't have a moral issue with consuming milk.
Half the world's population. It's no wonder, really, that
so many of us have some sort of problem with milk. We're mammals, yes, and do drink milk. We're designed to do so... until about age three, when we biologically are wired to wean from our mothers' milk. Then our bodies change. And many of us, unsurprisingly, become lactose intolerant. That is not to say all of us are lactose-intolerant. I've never had GI symptoms from drinking milk or eating cheese. My dairy-related symptoms are skin- and generally inflammation-related--from itchiness and eczema to sinusitis and more. These symptoms occur whether I have milk (full of lactose) or hard cheese (pretty much lactose-free). Of course these things are mild compared to true dairy allergy, which can be immediately serious. So those are a few of the health issues. There are more, of course, and some controversial. I may touch on a few of those in later posts, but for now I'd like to get on to dairy alternatives.
Non-dairy milks are quite popular right now. It used to be the only readily available type of non-dairy milk was soy. (There's a hot button issue if there ever was one. I am not anti-soy, but since my daughter and husband both have some intolerance to soy other than miso, tamari, and the occasional tempeh we tend to stay away from much of it. My personal view is "everything in moderation." Too much soy--
like too much of anything else--is probably bad for you. Small amounts are probably fine, so long as you don't have adverse reactions to it.) Now there are a ton of non-dairy milks--almond, hemp, coconut, rice, hazelnut, etc. I tend to make my own nut milks or purchase unsweetened hemp milk since I find the extra sugar and some of the thickeners to be really off-putting. As with many things, I like homemade versions better than store bought. My favorite? Homemade almond milk sweetened with a date or two and a pinch of Saigon cinnamon. Just in case you were curious.
Non-dairy "butters" are a little tougher to come by. Earth Balance is decent, but still tastes kind of fake to me now. It's just not as good as the real thing. Now here's where I stray from a lot of folks' opinions. I don't really like dairy alternatives. Yes, I
love almond milk. But I don't really consider it "milk." It's
almondmilk (one word, but I'll use two in my writing for the most part). Maybe you know what I mean. If you've made the homemade stuff, it's entirely different from store bought almond-not-dairy-milk in a carton. It tastes like
almonds, not milk. I don't want fake milk. I want something that tastes good on its own, for its own sake. I don't need fake milk with vitamin fortification. If I need vitamin D, I'll take
vitamin D. (I do, by the way, and chances are you do too. So get tested! /aside ) So non-dairy butters, like fortified and heavily-processed non-dairy "milks" are a little chemically for my tastes now. What does that have to do with Earth Balance? Nothing really, just that I don't really like it. I'm going to use a particular fat in my cooking for
its own sake, just like I use almond milk for almond milk's sake, or coconut milk in a Thai curry because coconut milk just
works. My favorites saturated fat for cooking is coconut oil because it just works. Refined or unrefined, based on the recipe's flavor profile. (Refined is more neutral.) Same qualities as butter for baking's sake, but no weird stuff. For a spread I use a little chilled olive oil. (It solidifies in the freezer, and makes a good spread when mixed with a little sea salt before freezing.)
And oh, since we're on the subject of foods for their own sake... Vegan "cheese."
Ugh. I have tried and tried to like vegan cheeses. You know, the sort of gelatinous ones you find on the grocery store shelves. I. Hate. Them. I hate Daiya. I hate the Vegan Gourmet stuff now. I don't really like the "cream cheese" alternatives--though I find them less offensive since I can make cheesecake with them. They all taste very plastic-y to me, have weird melting properties, and are generally just gross. Now, I do think there's a place for these products. They fill a void, and some people just can't eat cheeseless pizza without feeling deprived. I'd just rather not taste them or deal with them. For some reason, calling Tofutti slices "cheese" makes as much sense to me as calling Kraft singles "cheese." That is to say, it doesn't make much sense at all. (I readily admit that I was a bit of a cheese snob when I ate dairy, so this may color my opinion some.)
Now, I
do like some of the raw and cooked nut-based "cheeses" that are minimally-processed and often made at home. The Vegetarian Times "
feta" and "
goat cheese" are really, really good. I wouldn't call them cheese, but they're certainly a lot better than the pseudo-cheeses you can find in the grocery store. (Look at the ingredient list for those products next time you go shopping. Ick.) Nutritional yeast also makes for a mean "queso" dip and batch of mac 'n yeast. But I don't call those things cheese. They're not. They're nuts and/or yeast. They're delicious on their own.
Oh dear. I sound like a huge food snob. But maybe that's okay in this case. There are so many
products out there. And I do admit I buy some of them on occasion. In fact, I just recently bought hemp milk and some Amande almond yogurt. But so many are just that--
products. They're so highly processed that you can barely taste the original ingredients... and for what? Saying that they're "dairy alternatives"? Why not celebrate almonds for what they are? Or hemp milk? Or raw, cultured nut spreads? Since so many people should not for health reasons have dairy, can't we just start thinking of dairy as being a non-food for adults? Many vegans don't even look at milk and eggs--let alone meats--as food anymore. I'm not suggesting everyone go dairy free. If I could, I'd still probably have a little butter now and then. But it's worth a thought. Maybe more of us should view dairy that way, whether for our own immediate health or for environmental reasons. And let's start looking at dairy alternatives not as dairy alternatives but as separate entities. Hemp and almond milks not as faux dairy but as different beverages with unique qualities that taste completely
of themselves and are both delicious. Coconut oil as a great baking fat. Cultured coconut milk as, well, cultured coconut milk. And maybe we'd stop missing dairy so much if we opened our eyes to all the
real, whole, food alternatives out there.